Antonella “Nell” De Luca is the first in her family to go to college, and on a full ride, too. She’s spent three years studying nonstop to make the most of this chance. Now in her senior year at Rusk University, Nell realizes she’s seriously lacking a social life. So with the help of her friend Dylan, she creates The Ultimate College Bucket List, and the first item on her list is to hook up with a jock!

Wide receiver Mateo Torres likes to party when he’s not on the field. Because as long as things don’t get too serious, he can avoid thinking about the ex he lost.

Hooking up with Dylan’s friend, Nell, is the last thing he should do. She’s too much like the girl he spends all his time trying to forget. But when he gets a taste of Nell, he’s reluctant to give her up. Being around her almost feels like he’s getting a do-over. And he’s the perfect person to help Nell drop her inhibitions and complete her bucket list.

But as the list draws to a close, they’ll both have to decide if what they have is real or all played out.